charleston diocese lawsuit

Murdaugh judges own legal story unfolded in SC, Nikki Haley to campaign in Myrtle Beach this month, SC woman arrested after 9 puppies found in trash, Murdaughs attorneys to file appeal after guilty, Paid express lanes grow more popular in once-reluctant, After Murdaugh trial circus, Walterboro welcomes, Storms roll east after slamming South; 10 deaths, SCDOT receives project permit to continue I-526 corridor, Some California mountain residents could be snowed, Utah man who killed family was investigated by child, Defense lawyers in Idaho killings case want gag order, Lawsuit: Muslims praying at Missouri prison pepper-sprayed, Next steps for Alex Murdaugh after guilty verdict, Fmr. CHARLESTON, S.C. (WCBD) - The Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests (SNAP) is denouncing the Diocese of Charleston after allowing a priest to resume . Hh+4(PG Our childrens safety is of paramount importance.. A South Carolina man has filed a lawsuit in Horry County alleging a priest at St. Andrews Catholic Church in Myrtle Beach sexually abused him 30 years ago. Bishop Ruth Woodliff-Stanley of the Episcopal Diocese of South Carolina meets April 22 with Bishop Chip Edgar, her counterpart in the Anglican Church in North America, at Grace Church Cathedral in Charleston. Typically, The Greenville News does not identify alleged victims of sexual assault and abuse, however in this case, Jentsch-McKay has publicly identified herself in court documents. The Wheeling-Charleston Diocese has released a statement in response to a lawsuit filed by West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey, accusing the diocese of knowingly hiring pedophiles and . On April 22, they sat for a joint interview with a Post and Courier reporter. The Roman Catholic Diocese of Charleston covers the entire state of South Carolina with Charleston as its See city. Maria Aselage, director of the office of media relations for the Diocese of Charleston, responded to the lawsuit. Mwapecame to South Carolina to complete the course and later became a board hospital certified chaplainbefore returning toZambia. The Roman Catholic Diocese of Charleston and Bishop England High School are targets of a newly filed class action lawsuit seeking $300 million in compensation for students and their parents or . Theyre ready to move on, Sanderson told ENS. CHARLOTTE, N.C. Two men who previously accused former Diocese of Charlotte priests of sexual abuse stemming from the 70s and 80s have filed new assault . For over 20 years, leaders considered the window a safety aid, not a liability. CHARLESTON, S.C. (WSAV) A Savannah priest sexual abuse survivor will "not" be able to sue a South Carolina Catholic Diocese for the crimes he says happened to him 30 years ago in the "Concealment of Mwapes conduct (and sexually abusive priests in general) has been the hallmark and policy of the Diocese and the Catholic Church.". [*+CUJ@vbyv#C@*!EC@Im*5?"%? Manuela Jentsch-McKay, the woman suing Mwape, also did not respond to emails for comment. To strengthen our efforts to ensure the safety of our young people, I have asked for onsite audits of parish and school safe environment measures to be conducted annually in our Diocese rather than every three years, he added. Mwape, a native of Zambia, has been in the priesthood for 25 years. Though mineral income trended higher in 2022, stock and bond markets took a hit, Brennan said. Father Babick has voluntarily stepped aside from regular ministerial responsibilities for a period of time., Documenting the Catholic Sexual Abuse and Financial Crisis Data on bishops, priests, brothers, nuns, Pope Francis, Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Documenting the Abuse Crisis in the Roman Catholic Church Established June 2003, https://abcnews4.com/news/local/lawsuit-accuses-charleston-priest-of-sexual-abuse-of-former-student. Today's breaking news and more in your inbox, Copyright The Intelligencer | https://www.theintelligencer.net | 1500 Main Street, Wheeling, WV 26003 | 304-233-0100. While eight of the ACNA parishes that had been worshipping in those churches ask for a review of the decision, no one has contested the transfer of the other six church properties. She is seeking an unspecified amount in damages. El Avivamiento Eucarstico Nacional es la respuesta gozosa, expectante y popular de toda la Iglesia Catlica en los Estados Unidos a la invitacin divina de volver a centrar nuestras vidas en la Presencia Real de la Eucarista. The Most Rev. Diocesan support for both was up significantly in 2022. An attorney for Mwape and the Diocese of Charleston were not listed in public court records by Wednesday. But Richter also is worried about students from other schools who used the locker room before games. . . He said that several parishes and schools had been able to retire some long-term debt through fundraising campaigns. If you are looking for a parish community, we can help you find one close to you. Mwape would later use hotel rooms paid for using a credit card from the Diocese of Charleston to continue the relationship, the woman said. Get to know what schools we have in each deanery of the state: Aiken The ruling likely signals the final chapter in a schism begun in 2012 that forced many remaining members of the sharply diminished Episcopal diocese to join other nearby Episcopal congregations or plant new churches. The lawsuit alleges that the church knowingly employed priests who had been accused of abuse. Youth Ministers Richter hopes that's true, but said anyone who may have fallen victim to a predator using the window should be entitled to compensation, even without video evidence. His final year as bishop included fending off a lawsuit filed in New York in 2019 that alleged Guglielmone sexually abused an 8-year-old boy while pastoring on Long Island in the late 1970s. Babick has been the parish administrator at Lady of Good Counsel Catholic Church in Folly Beach. West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey announced a lawsuit against the Diocese of Wheeling-Charleston and Bishop Michael Bransfield on Tuesday, March 19, 2019. !M*CT? GREENVILLE, S.C. . The lawsuit claims the diocese was or should have been aware of improper sexual relationships . The Wheeling-Charleston diocese includes nearly 75,000 Catholics and 95 parishes throughout West Virginia. Learn how the Diocese of Charleston protects children and creates safe environments for our youth. V@8$ze'DC?^n4rG|%}sI0j]Lghpn+r{PFXjmQ~Avgk;?Xa(1Npv,;I@DW[{c>XAl6w*Qm|vezpyTM[YcB:M'<9 i# Ahprz;Xs)WoS/xEAmhs3 $B:B> sq: Several top churchmen received tens of thousands of dollars in church-funded personal gifts from Bransfield during his tenure in Wheeling-Charleston, which covers the entirety of one of the poorest U.S. states. Theres an imperative to explore whether we cant move forward in a very different sort of spirit than we have been in the past, Edgar told the newspaper. The lawsuit alleges that the church knew about McLeans behavior and covered it up. Talk of schism led to lawsuits in dioceses across the United States as conservative leaders sought to lead their congregations out of The Episcopal Church. Stay connected! Copyright 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. With about 7,500 members in 31 congregations, it is focused on advocating for racial and social justice in its communities, fostering healing among its congregations and building the future church, Woodliff-Stanley said. The facility, located south of Charleston on Seabrook Island, is a test of the dioceses ability to work out differences amicably, Woodliff-Stanley said. She called it an opportunity to begin developing a model that we hope will be grounded in Gospel values, a model for how to work together across these lines of difference., And with the court case mostly resolved, were eager to redirect resources toward the more central aims of the Gospel and away from conflict, Woodliff-Stanley said. Who can sue In March of 2019, the diocese released a list of priests with credible allegations of abuse of minors and McLean was on that list. Photo: Molly Hamilton. While home on a break from his studies, the student says he met Babick for dinner. The lawsuit states Mwape used different Catholic churches as his homes and used them to pursue, groom and have sex with Jentsch-McKay. The Bishop of Charleston, a Corporation Sole, dba Roman Catholic Diocese of Charleston which oversees 33 K-12 schools in South Carolina, and the South Carolina Independent Colleges and Universities (SCICU), a nonprofit organization whose membership includes five Historically Black Colleges and Universities, have filed a lawsuit to prevent state . While I definitely understand the severity of what I did, I can assure you that the video never did go anywhere else, Scofield said at his bond hearing. Bransfield wasnt included. How to Report an Allegation Attorneys allege the victim then went unconscious and woke up naked with the chaplain allegedly performing a sex act on him. "Mwape exploited this knowledge and engaged Plaintiff in increasing forms of sexual behavior. Bransfield served as the bishop of the Wheeling-Charleston Diocese from 2005 until his resignation . He was sentenced to two years in prison, which was suspended to 18 months of probation, then ordered to register as a sex offender and undergo mental-health treatment. None of the persons named still serves as a priest. Earlier this year, West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey accused the diocese and Bransfield in a lawsuit of knowingly employing pedophiles and failing to conduct adequate background checks on camp and school workers. Reach Rickey Dennis at 937-4886. The diocese covers the entire state of South Carolina and has 33 K-12 schools. Of the Episcopalians whose churches were claimed by ACNA after the 2012 split, some began forming new congregations meeting in living rooms, on boat docks, in taverns and in a funeral home. Copyright 2022 WCSC. Published: Nov. 8, 2021 at 11:39 AM PST. 148 Williman Street The live-filmed cop show featuring Richland and Berkeley deputies, On Patrol: Live, is now on the streaming service Peacock, with the potential to reach a wider audience. In a statement released in response to the state's lawsuit, the diocese . Updated: Jan. 4, 2021 at 2:54 PM PST. Diocese of Charleston Faces Two Priest Abuse Lawsuits. Gene Robinson of New Hampshire as the first openly gay bishop in the church. In December 2006, leaders in the diocese of San Joaquin were the first to vote to sever ties with The Episcopal Church. Before then,he was pastor atHoly Trinity Church in Orangeburg. Episcopalians and departing Anglicans in South Carolina have received final word in a mixed ruling that concludes the last major church property dispute in the North American Anglican realignment. A year later, Scofield pleaded guilty to a single count of voyeurism, saying his crime was a one-time occurrence. He has disputed the findings of Loris investigation, telling The Post none of it is true, but declining detailed comment on the advice of his lawyers. Today, the Episcopal diocese appears ready to move on. But video of naked students was discovered on a school computer back in May of 2019, and the lawsuit states the schools sports information director made the videos. 1998 - 2023 Nexstar Media Inc. | All Rights Reserved. Diocesan leaders also are working out the transfer of St. Christopher Camp and Conference Center back to the Episcopal diocese. The remaining diocese counted 22 continuing parishes and missions. Their purpose wasto allow coaches to monitor for fights, bullying, smoking or any type of inappropriate activity thatmight occur within the locker rooms. RCIA / Adult Ed. She alleges one of the priests, Frederick Austin McLean, repeatedly abused her and her sister when they were kids. In October 2012, the newly established Disciplinary Board for Bishops concluded that Lawrence was guilty of abandoning the church because of legal and canonical steps he and other diocesan leaders had taken to sever their Episcopal affiliation. "This case stems from the Catholic Churchs continued failure to police their priests," the lawsuit states in its opening page. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. The Most Rev. Parish and Office Staff Discontent also had been simmering under the surface because some conservative dioceses at that time still objected to womens ordination, which convention approved in 1976. Two weeks later, on May 6, the ACNA diocese announced it would not seek a review of the state Supreme Courts ruling. Increased parishioner support of the 2022 Catholic Sharing Appeal enabled the diocese to earmark funds for parish food pantries, Catholic school tuition assistance and other outreach efforts towards children and families, regardless of religious affiliation. Low 53F. There are some folks grieving the loss, Woodliff-Stanley said of Episcopalians in her diocese. In 2021, a $300 million class action suit was filed against the diocese and Bishop England, claiming an employee recorded minors in a locker room. He strongly denied ever abusing anyone and the diocese said it had disproved the claims. Phil Allen and Steve Olson, two deacons at the parish in West Greenville, declined to comment. The pastor of a Catholic church in Greenville has been placed on administrative leave after he was accused of using his position of authority to have a secret sexual relationship with one of his parishioners, according to a lawsuit filed in Orangeburg County this week. We have support and resources at the diocese to make your life easier. He'll represent them along with attorneys from Solomon Law Group; Slotchiver & Slotchiver; and Brent Souther Halversen LLC. We will respond to the pleading in due time. Brennan also mentioned that the diocese also saw more lawsuit settlements in the fiscal year of 2022. Fr. Currently, the diocese consists of 96 parishes and 21 missions, with Charleston as its see city. , Post and Courier, an Evening Post Publishing Newspaper Group. Aselage said the diocese takes the protection of children "very seriously.". The lawsuit said Mwape's behavior was covered up by the diocese and reflects a pattern of abuse in other Catholic churches. Under the category of investigations, suits and related, the diocese spent a little over $2.4 million, compared to more than $3 million the fiscal year before. Fifteen Anglican parishes, including the historic St. Michael's Church and St. Philip's Church in Charleston . WHEELING Though economic factors led to an unrealized loss in assets of nearly $29 million, the Most Rev. CHARLESTON, S.C. (WCSC) - The Catholic Diocese of Charleston is facing a new lawsuit. But attorney Larry Richter, who has represented victims in previous lawsuits against the diocese, said at a news conference in his Mount Pleasant office on Feb. 4 that perspective is shortsighted at best. Grace Beahm Alford gbeahm@postandcourier.com, Bishop England High faces $300M lawsuit over windows that let staff watch kids change, By Sara Coello and Rickey Ciapha Dennis Jr. All rights reserved. When school officials learned about a member of its athletic staff videotaping boys in the locker room in May 2019, they immediately contacted police and terminated the employee. A new lawsuit has been filed against the Diocese of Charleston alleging assault and battery by a former chaplain at Bishop England High School on Daniel Island. Even members with deep generational ties to St. Pauls were accepting of the court ruling that left their former church in ACNAs hands, he said. Attorneys representing the case held a press conference in Mount Pleasant on Thursday. YouTube / Diocese of Charleston (Scott McCloskey/The Intelligencer via AP/AP) Charleston, W.Va. Updated: 11:41 PM EDT April 14, 2020. Each window was visible from within, but students can't see through the blinds, Richter said. Diocese of Wheeling-Charleston Wants Former Bishop Michael Bransfield Case Dismissed Joselyn King, Wheeling Intelligencer, May 11, 2019 Authorities arrested the sports information director, Jeffrey Alan Scofield, now 34, and the school promptly fired him. gyee@postandcourier.com rdennis@postandcourier.com, By Avery G. Wilks ), filed by John Doe 197. Episcopal leaders consider the case effectively closed. We continue to pay for counseling for victims of abuse or harassment from funds derived from the sale of the former episcopal residence and the return of some money from the previous bishop. South Carolina leaders accelerated their plans to leave the church in 2012 after General Convention approved rites for blessing same-sex unions. Roe was part of the St. John Catholic Church and School where McLean was a priest and teacher with regular contact with children. The Diocese of Wheeling-Charleston (Latin: Dioecesis Vhelingensis-Carolopolitanus) is a Latin Church ecclesiastical territory, or diocese, of the Catholic Church comprising the U.S. state of West Virginia.The ordinary is Bishop Mark E. Brennan.The diocese maintains two cathedrals: the Cathedral of Saint Joseph in Wheeling, West Virginia, and the Basilica of the Co-Cathedral of the Sacred . ]t)Wm]~C|j]g)}_TwX.]^]j{v^]N>\s-Oo\7 o( :GW6jw]mG^pO\$vW! ABC News 4 reached out to the Diocese of Charleston, who provided the following statement: We have received a copy of the lawsuit and are currently reviewing it. Founded in 1820 by Pope Pius VII, it is one . For some reason, the suit states he was referred to a fertility counselor to address the trauma. A judge asked the West Virginia Supreme Court on Wednesday to consider the viability of Attorney General Patrick Morrisey's lawsuit alleging that the Wheeling Charleston-Diocese knowingly hired . We received notice of this lawsuit late this afternoon and will be responding in due course, Aselage said. We are pleased and grateful that the Circuit Court of Wood County, West Virginia has concurred with the position of the Diocese of Wheeling-Charleston that the complaint brought by Attorney General Morrisey is not valid. Bransfield had been investigated for an alleged groping incident in 2007 and was implicated in court testimony in 2012 in an infamous Philadelphia priestly sex abuse case. Under the category . "It is best to think of the grooming by offenders as a gradual, calculated process.". Safe Haven Training The victim filed a report weeks after the alleged incident happened. The diocese has faced several sex-abuse accusations dating to the 1950s and 1960s, with victims accusing priests and parochial school employees of abuse. Jentsch-McKay, through the lawsuit, is seeking damages to be determined by a jury based on severe pain, suffering and mental anguish. He came to the U.S. in 2000 for graduatestudies inWashington state. KBna5vtzWX%?aV\;S3'0= X1*jHo36XXJ r!10_66#n1g}%sJ~A7XQ|i The Episcopal and ACNA dioceses now are in talks about how to carry out the courts order that 14 church properties be returned to the Episcopal diocese. Since then, Episcopalians in South Carolina have found ways to worship and serve their communities amid a series of legal victories and setbacks in the church property lawsuit. Even after that list was published, the lawsuit states there was no effort on the churchs part to locate Roe as one of his victims. Ignatius, Discernment, and You with the Rev. The lawsuit, filed on behalf of students and parents at Bishop England High School, seeks tuition refunds and damages for every child who might have been seen. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Dr. Mark Bozzuti-Jones, African American Readings of St. Paul with Dr. Lisa Bowens, Returning & Becoming: Kanuga Christian Formation, Two-Year Spiritual Direction Training Course, Life Together Fellow, Church of Our Saviour, Milton, MA, Graduate Resident Youth or Childrens Minister. Its a problem of what this does to the rest of his professional life of course, it wrecks his faith life this man wanted to give his life to the church, says the plaintiffs attorney Lawrence Richter. The findings, first reported by The Washington Post, determined Bransfield had spent church funds on dining out, liquor, personal travel and luxury items, as well as personal gifts to fellow bishops and cardinals in the U.S. and Vatican. A former personal altar server sued ex-Bishop Michael Bransfield and the diocese in March, saying he was sexually assaulted in 2014 and harassed for years prior. PARKERSBURG The Wheeling-Charleston Diocese has filed a motion to dismiss a lawsuit filed by West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey's office alleging it and a former bishop knowingly . The terms of the recent settlement are confidential, Wheeling-Charleston Diocese spokesman Tim Bishop said in a statement, Wednesday, Aug. 21, 2019. ;5x-yfna>W>6tmCUW:p}1}y(^ ^V)'@50?mmARi*O Q1(3[K\GY~&EYD1!N.yf>GtE%E7ZJ`lZd~'rC9`41M2w;B?Vuwl^'Wv3Y;d)P ESc,?w'Mm:HhC&B11o5)YO? `2%ks?d?VG3k0iZ x8nB4J|N=7w=?VWxJ`5N)k}:w?i|3ePUuhCqQ[XX%IT8+B}p9 A new lawsuit accuses a Charleston priest of sexual abuse. Case Details Parties Documents Dockets. Charleston, S.C., Apr 15, 2021 / 18:01 pm America/Denver (CNA). Do you work at your parish or school? According to the audit, mineral rights investments jumped from $52.1 million in 2021 to $64.9 million in 2022. We are impacting the lives of our brothers and sisters both spiritually and physically but there is still much to do. State Law Enforcement Division/Provided. X6|sb /T^9k,taRW'Mf\:^AJV =tU[5g(`WSQQuw'#]~2~)N\KHL053]ZCK_#N#lR'fY,\uDCd06&6_iNNGBDA|. The charges were filed by a woman referred to as Mary Roe 1818. Additionally, Catholic school teachers and staff are required to attend boundary training.. The lawsuit was filed by Bishop of Charleston, a Corporation Sole, dba Roman Catholic Diocese of Charleston, on behalf of its 33 K-12 schools throughout the State of South Carolina. Babick was a priest he says hes known since his days as a Bishop England student. To learn more about ChatGPT and how we can inspire students, we sat down with BestReviews book expert, Ciera Pasturel. The diocese declined further comment. Reach him at dgross@greenvillenews.com or on Twitter @danieljgross. Episcopal membership in the diocese dropped below 6,400 right after Lawrence and his followers departed. Rachel Martin talks to West Virginia Attorney General Patrick Morrisey, who sued the Catholic diocese of Wheeling-Charleston Tuesday saying it and its former bishop "knowingly employed . As attendance grew, services moved to a local barbeque restaurant, and in 2013, the congregation began leasing the sanctuary of the New First Baptist Missionary Church, where it worships today as The Episcopal Church on Edisto. Daniel J. The diocese released its annual audit Thursday afternoon. Ketia Daniel, founder of BHM Cleaning Co., is BestReviews cleaning expert. We must continue to fund programs focused on charitable works, outreach, education and evangelization. [Episcopal News Service] Episcopalians in the Diocese of South Carolina are looking to the future after the state Supreme Court, ruling largely in the dioceses favor last month, offered a note of relative finality to the dioceses decade-long legal battle with a breakaway group over its claim to Episcopal church property. On Edisto Island southwest of Charleston, the vestry of Trinity Episcopal Church voted in 2012 to leave The Episcopal Church. Columbia ACNA Bishop Chip Edgar, also newly consecrated as of March, agreed, and the two met at Grace Church Cathedral in Charleston. TheRoman CatholicDiocese of Charleston is also named as a defendant in the lawsuit. The court concluded a group that left the church and joined the Anglican Church in North America, or ACNA, must return 14 church properties it claimed in 2012 to the Episcopal Diocese of South Carolina, as well as diocesan properties that include St. Christopher Camp and Conference Center on Seabrook Island. Bishop Robert E. Guglielmone said in 2019 the list was released "in the spirit of transparency" and hoped publishing the names would bring healings to victims and their families. Members who wanted to remain Episcopalians began worshipping instead in homes with the help of retired priests. CHARLESTON, W.Va. (AP) A lawsuit accusing the former bishop of West Virginias Roman Catholic diocese of molesting boys and men has been settled. In April, two separate suits were filed claiming negligence against the diocese connected to that voyeurism case. [{7XzdBiewMF"w [I&?K9s;A{R:i0nHWzg1>Z:6miQc. Myrtle Beach Keep checking counton2.com for updates. Mwape became the pastor ofSt. Anthony of Padua Catholic Church in West Greenville back in 2020 after being assigned there by the Dioceses of Charleston. Victim Assistance. We feel that there is finality here, and it has been a long arc, Woodliff-Stanley told ENS. Neither Mwape or the woman and her lawyer responded to messages from the newspaper. Read more2 men dead in Charleston after separate fatal shootings on the same day, The Post and Courier School Teachers The diocese declined further comment. Northwest of Charleston, in Summerville, Episcopalians previously had worshiped at St. Pauls Episcopal Church. The defendant was also a former chaplain at Bishop England High School . Robert E. Guglielmone, the bishop of Charleston, speaks Wednesday, April 14, 2021, at a news conference regarding a federal lawsuit that has been filed seeking to remove the Blaine Amendment from the South Carolina Constitution. The complaint states in May 2019, after the victim graduated from a seminary college, he met . Each locker room had a glass window, about 4 by 4 feet, embedded into a wall that leads to a staff office. The case status is Pending - Other Pending. This lawsuit filed in Charleston County is just the latest in a string of lawsuits claiming misconduct in the Diocese of Charleston. Independently, however, eight ACNA parishes filed a petition requesting their own reviews of the ruling, a process less lengthy or extensive than an appeal. document.getElementById("demo").innerHTML = "© " + html; Dr. Mark Bozzuti-Jones, Churchwide Global Mission Conference: Journey Into Healing. Follow him on Twitter @RCDJunior. He can be reached at dpaulsen@episcopalchurch.org. The Catholic Appeal of South Carolina (CASC) is the primary source of funding for many critical ministries. The Allegations The suit says for two decades Bishop England students were required to get undressed in school lockers rooms that left them "subject to viewing . Theyre not looking back. Parochial report data show that the dioceses baptized membership topped 29,000 in 2011, the year before the diocese was upended by theological and doctrinal disputes, especially related to full LGBTQ+ inclusion in the church. While some of the students who were identified from recordings have been contacted individually, Richter said it's possible thousands of former students and their families should be eligible. The Diocese of Charleston filed a suit against South Carolina on Wednesday challenging the state's "Blaine Amendment", which prohibits public funds . Also the dioceses three pastoral centers in Huttonsville, Charleston and the Eastern Panhandle have evolved in their use, which has led to added cost savings. 3 0 obj Bryan Babick, Bishop of Charleston, The, Bishop of the Diocese of Charleston, The ( Filing fee $ 402 receipt number ASCDC-10387106. The Roman Catholic Diocese of Charleston is an ecclesiastical territory, or diocese, of the Roman Catholic Church in the Southern United States that comprises the entire state of South Carolina. The National Eucharistic Revival is the joyful, expectant, grassroots response of the entire Catholic Church in the United States to the divine invitation of re-centering our lives on the Real Presence of the Eucharist.

How To Change Split Screen To Vertical On Modern Warfare, What Happens To Standard Deviation When Mean Is Multiplied, Articles C